Question 71

Ms. Kang should ask Dominique, "Why do you think the boy wanted to buy a gift for his friend?"

This question encourages Dominique to engage with the character's motivations and emotions, promoting deeper comprehension of the story's themes and character development.

A) "Why do you think the boy wanted to buy a gift for his friend?"

This question is effective as it prompts critical thinking about character motivations and the underlying themes of friendship and generosity. It encourages Dominique to analyze the boy's feelings and intentions, fostering a deeper understanding of the narrative.

B) "What color hat was the boy wearing in the beginning of the story?"

While this question checks for recall of specific details, it does not promote deeper understanding or analysis of the story's themes. This type of question focuses on surface-level details rather than the characters' motivations or the story's broader implications.

C) "How might the story end differently if the character lived on a farm instead of in a city?"

This question is more hypothetical and speculative, which may lead to interesting discussions but does not directly address the key themes or character motivations present in the original story. It diverts focus from the actual narrative to an alternate scenario that may not be relevant to understanding the text.

D) "If you were the boy, would you have made the same choice at the end of the story, and why?"

This question encourages personal reflection and critical thinking about the boy's decision, but it may be too dependent on Dominique's personal experiences rather than fostering an understanding of the character's motives or the story's message itself. It could lead to varied responses that may not enhance comprehension of the story.

Conclusion

Asking about the boy's motivation to buy a gift directly engages with the themes of the story and encourages critical thinking about character development. Options B, C, and D, while they may provide some engagement, do not foster the same level of insight or critical analysis as option A. Therefore, option A is the most effective question for promoting a deeper understanding of the narrative.