81. If a policyowner surrenders a policy for its cash value, when is a tax liability incurred?

Answer: A

Explanation:

Tax liability is incurred when the cash value exceeds all premiums paid.

A tax liability arises at the moment a policyowner surrenders a policy for its cash value, specifically when the cash value received surpasses the total premiums that have been paid into the policy.

A) The cash value exceeds all premiums paid

This option is correct as it aligns with the tax regulations governing life insurance policies. When the cash value exceeds the total premiums paid, the amount received is considered taxable income, generating a tax liability for the policyholder.

B) The cash value is less than premiums paid

This option is incorrect because if the cash value is less than the premiums paid, there is no taxable gain. In such cases, the policyholder has not realized any income from the surrender, thus no tax liability is incurred.

C) The policy is exchanged for a policy of equal value

This option is also incorrect. An exchange of a policy for another of equal value, often referred to as a 1035 exchange, allows policyholders to defer tax liabilities. Therefore, no tax is incurred at the moment of exchange.

D) The policy is transferred to a third party

This option is incorrect as well. Transferring a policy to a third party does not automatically incur tax liability unless the transaction results in a gain that exceeds the premiums paid. Without a gain, there is no immediate tax implication.

Conclusion

In summary, the correct answer is A because tax liability is only incurred when the cash value exceeds the total premiums paid into the policy. Options B, C, and D fail to recognize the conditions under which tax liabilities arise, focusing instead on scenarios that do not result in taxable income.