Question 14

People in lasting relationships can still surprise each other.

The excerpt illustrates how William Tavener, despite his strong demeanor and controlling nature, has moments of surprise regarding his wife's assertiveness and directness. Hester's unexpected suggestion to let the boys attend the circus highlights the dynamic where even a seemingly rigid relationship can have elements of surprise.

A) Disagreements can strain even the closest relationships

While the excerpt does hint at underlying tensions, particularly in William's reaction to Hester's agitation, it does not primarily focus on disagreements as a theme. Instead, it showcases moments of connection and surprise rather than an emphasis on strain.

B) Cooperative relationships allow people to grow to their full potential.

This option suggests a theme of collaboration leading to personal growth, which is not the central focus of the excerpt. While Hester's influence is noted, the relationship dynamics portrayed do not explicitly highlight growth through cooperation but rather the surprising elements in their interactions.

C) Children bring strife that challenges bonds in a relationship.

Although children are mentioned in the context of the family's dynamics, the excerpt does not present them as a source of strife. Instead, the emphasis is on Hester's relationship with William and her assertiveness, making this option less relevant to the central theme.

D) People in lasting relationships can still surprise each other.

This statement accurately captures the essence of the excerpt, as it portrays Hester's unexpected and direct approach in her relationship with William. His surprise at her assertive suggestion about the circus reflects how long-standing relationships can still hold moments of unforeseen revelations.

Conclusion

The correct answer, D, effectively encapsulates the theme that even within established relationships, individuals can still surprise one another, as demonstrated by Hester's boldness. Other options fail to address the core of the narrative, which revolves around the nuances of their relationship rather than conflict, cooperation, or the role of children.