Question 16

Alice's previous owners said that they had experienced supernatural events as well.

This evidence directly supports the conclusion that the basement has a ghost, as it indicates a history of supernatural occurrences associated with the property, lending credibility to Alice's fears.

A) The previous owners said that they had experienced supernatural events as well

This option provides relevant evidence that suggests a likelihood of supernatural activity in the basement, as the previous owners' experiences can be taken as credible reports of haunting. Such testimonials can contribute significantly to the belief in the presence of a ghost, especially in an old house with a spooky reputation.

B) The country cemetery is a mile from Alice's house

While the proximity of a cemetery may evoke thoughts of the supernatural, it does not provide direct evidence of a ghost in Alice's basement. Cemeteries are often associated with death, but this connection is too tenuous to conclude that there is a ghost in her home, as many houses are located near cemeteries without any haunting implications.

C) Alice's horoscope said that she would have an unexpected encounter

This option is based on a belief in astrology rather than tangible evidence. While it may suggest that Alice could face something unusual, it does not specifically indicate that this encounter is of a supernatural nature or that it relates to the basement. Therefore, it lacks relevance in supporting the conclusion that there is a ghost.

D) There were cobwebs in the corner of the stair leading to the basement

The presence of cobwebs is indicative of neglect or lack of activity in the basement but does not serve as evidence of a ghost. Cobwebs can form in any area that is not frequently disturbed, so they do not provide any direct link to supernatural occurrences.

Conclusion

The only option that provides relevant evidence to conclude the basement has a ghost is A, which relies on the experiences of previous owners. All other options either lack direct relevance or are based on circumstantial connections that do not support the conclusion about a ghost's presence in the basement. Therefore, A stands out as the definitive choice.